"The Uncommon Reader"
(Reviewed by Mary Whipple SEP 14, 2007)
"As a girl, one of [the Queen's] greatest thrills had been on VE night when she and her sister had slipped out of the gates and mingled unrecognized with the crowds. There was something of that, she felt, to reading. It was anonymous; it was shared; it was common. And she who had led a life apart now found that she craved it. There in these pages and between these covers she could go unrecognized."
Chasing after her rowdy dog-pack one day, the Queen discovers them barking at a "removal-like van," a bookmobile, parked outside the kitchen at Windsor. Entering the mobile library to apologize for the din, the Queen meets Norman Seakins, a young man from the kitchen whose primary interest is in gay books and photography. Feeling obligated to take a book, the Queen borrows a novel by Ivy Compton-Burnett, intending to return it the following week when the bookmobile returns.
Almost immediately, her life changes. That night, when the president of France arrives, she abandons her usual safe conversation and, addressing the president, remarks, "I've been longing to ask you about the writer Jean Genet…Homosexual and jailbird, was he nevertheless, as bad as he was painted?" The French president, unbriefed on this topic, knows it's going to be a long evening.
As the Queen's reading tastes expand, often under the direction of Norman, whom she promotes to being her "amanuensis," she becomes less interested in the day-to-day activities of state. She arrives late to the opening of Parliament because Norman had to fetch the book she wanted to read in the coach during the procession. She no longer keeps to the tried and true conversational subjects (the traffic on the road to the palace), raising new topics, unexpectedly, as she mixes with the public and meets honored guests. People become confused and alarmed by her spontaneous questions, and members of the general public become tongue-tied when the Queen asks them what they are reading. Dinner conversations no longer have the pleasant, easy-going atmosphere that once made invitations to the palace such memorable occasions.
Her family is delighted by her reading—she leaves them alone and gives them more freedom than ever before—but the press notes that she is less careful of her dress, sometimes wearing the same outfit to two events in the same month. Her equerries worry that she has Alzheimer's because she's constantly writing things down. Eventually, the Prime Minister becomes alarmed, after being ignored during an interminable weekend at Balmoral because the Queen was reading. He determines to stop this activity.
In this wickedly wry novella, Alan Bennett explores reading, writing, and their effects on our lives as he develops this imaginative and warmly humorous scenario. Though the eponymous "uncommon reader" is the Queen, her reactions to her reading (and other people's responses to her as a result of her reading) are so true-to-life and so plausible that Bennett accomplishes a feat rarely even attempted—he makes the reader identify with the Queen of England in her increasingly voracious reading habits. Soon she is keeping a journal of her reading, and Bennett's fans and readers of this novella will be rooting for her triumph as a bibliophile.
Bennett's humor has always depended on the fine line he creates between reality and absurdity, and his explorations into the absurd are so close to reality, or what we might wish reality to be, that the reader sees, ironically, the absurdity of reality itself. The Queen's real life, which some consider absurd on its face, plays into Bennett's hands here, as he posits an alternative "reading lifestyle," one to which many of his readers are firmly committed. He is respectful of the Queen here, making her seem human (though perhaps that, in and of itself, will be thought disrespectful by traditionalists) and connected with her public in new ways. Bennett keeps the humor low-key, evoking images which allow the reader to discover, unassisted, the ironies which are so hilarious throughout the novella.
As the Queen takes full charge of her life, the reader begins to wonder how Bennett will ever end this wonderful romp of a book. Then he surprises us with a perfect, climactic ending, which takes place on her eightieth birthday. Dramatist that he is, Bennett knows exactly when to stop. And does.
- Amazon readers rating: from 152 review
"The Clothes They Stood Up In & The Lady in the Van"
(Reviewed by Amanda Richards SEP 14, 2007)
There are two stories in this slim package, both dealing with people’s relationships with their possessions.
In the first, Mr. and Mrs. Ransome return from the opera to find their flat totally empty. The casserole has disappeared along with the oven, and even the toilet paper’s gone. Mr. Ransome mostly misses his stereo equipment (and of course the toilet paper) but cheers up when he remembers that he can upgrade his technology with the insurance refund.
Mrs. Ransome quickly gets over her shock, and begins shopping for the bare essentials to tide them over until the insurance cheque arrives. During this exercise, she rediscovers the simple things and learns that life without all her accumulated baggage isn’t that bad after all.
When the mystery is revealed, Mrs. Ransome has a whole new outlook on life, and although her husband has also changed, he hasn’t evolved as much as she has. This is a story with some very funny bits, but also with some important messages for all of us.
The other (shorter) story is about an eccentric woman who makes her home in a van, surrounded by everything she owns. Also very funny, it is so rich in description that your nose turns up whenever the author takes you inside the van.
If you’re looking for an entertaining read, and don’t feel like tackling a whole book, this one is highly recommended.
- Amazon readers rating: from 18 reviews
(back to top)
Bibliography: (with links to Amazon.com)
- The Madness of King George (1992)
- The Laying on of Hands: Stories (2000)
- The Clothes They Stood Up In (2001)
- The Uncommon Reader (2007)
- Smut: Two Unseemly Stories (January 2012))
(back to top)
- Wikipedia page on Alan Bennett
- Tim Domestic interview with Alan Bennett
- Guardian Unlimited review of Untold Stories
- Guardian Unlimited review of The History Boys
- Library Journal review of The Uncommon Reader
(back to top)
About the Author:
Alan Bennett was born in 1934 in Leeds, Yorkshire, the son of a Co-op butcher. Bennett attended Leeds Modern School (a former state grammar school), learned Russian at the Joint Services School for Linguists during his National Service, and gained a place at Cambridge University. He was accepted by Exeter College, Oxford University and went on to take a first-class degree in history. While at Oxford he performed comedy with a number of future successful actors in the Oxford Revue. He was to remain at Oxford for several years researching and teaching Medieval History before deciding he was not cut out to be an academic.
Bennett is a distinguished British screenwriter, playwright and occasionally an actor. In the latter capacity, Bennett is best known as one of the 1960's "Beyond the Fringe" comedy troupe, where he was the most unobtrusive member of the lively group that included Dudley Moore, Peter Cook, and Jonathan Miller. He also wrote for the show. As a writer, Bennett is highly regarded for his ability to create detailed, memorable character sketches of complicated men. His work has appeared on stage, screen, and television.