(Jump over to read a review of The Broker)
(Jump over to read a review of Bleachers)
"Skipping Christmas "
(Reviewed by Nandini Pandya DEC 16, 2003)
Skipping Christmas starts with a very promising and original premise: Do we have to spend huge gobs of money and drive ourselves crazy each year in the name of the "Holidays?" Luther Krank, an accountant by profession, thinks he has the answer. And it is a loud and resounding "No." He is outraged at the thought that his family spends as much as 10% of its Adjusted Gross Income on the Holidays. He is also quite tired of attending the obligatory parties, buying the obligatory gifts and making the expected community contributions ("buying" one more calendar from the local police, fruit cakes that nobody eats from the firemen). So much better, he thinks, to skip the whole thing to go away on a ten-day cruise - and save half his annual Holiday expenses to boot. He is so convinced of the rightness of his idea that he manages to infect both his reluctant wife Nora and his already-half-converted colleague to go along with his idea.
But, this is much easier said than done. Nora's reluctant compliance is constantly challenged by feelings of inadequacy as she must "explain" herself to her friends. In fact, it is only Luther's heroic resolve that carries them through the onslaught of hostility from their neighbors. The hostility ranges from loud singing of Christmas carols outside their home to being questioned by their minister to being featured in their local newspaper with a picture of their "unlit at Christmas" home. I found this depiction quite difficult to believe because it is at odds with other valued American traits - rugged individuality, tolerance for differences, and respect for privacy. In fact, in this section the book takes on a decidedly "film noir" persona.
In the final third of the book, Grisham goes about undoing the case for skipping Christmas made so convincingly up to this point. Luther himself gives in because he cannot bear to reveal to his grown daughter who returns unexpectedly from Peru that they are not doing Christmas this year. The neighbors that had been depicted as the ugly face of the Christmas spirit forget their anger and come together to execute a picture-perfect Christmas for the Kranks. This "unskipping" of Christmas is so contrived and tortured, it appears to have been written by someone other than Grisham.
As a first-generation American and a cultural Hindu at that, I have found myself at odds with the overwhelming "Christmas spirit" that makes its appearance in the days after Halloween and lingers on into the first week of the New Year. It is not that I have an objection to the message of Christmas - celebrating the birth of Jesus, giving gifts to those who are near and dear to us and getting together with family, friends and colleagues so a good time can be had by all. Rather, my objection to the Holiday cheer is the unrelenting nature of it - the desire to do more, do it bigger, do it better - and do it in ever more celebratory / self-congratulatory ways. Holiday-themed toilet seat covers, anyone?
If this little novel is supposed to be the triumph of the Christmas spirit, it is a sorry one indeed. It is like saying buy MORE even if you don't need it and will never use it. Never mind the damage to the family pocketbook, never mind the damage to the environment, never mind that most of the goodies are made by poorly-paid elves in China. For, the spirit will prevail - but only after it has first taken a holiday in the form of boorishness and bad behavior. However there are two other aspects that really take the "Christmas" cake and leave a bad taste in my mouth.
One is the fact that the Kranks are relieved to find that their daughter's Peruvian fiancee is not dark at all - in fact, glory of glories - he is "two shades lighter." I am shocked that an acclaimed author like Grisham wrote such an openly racist scene and that the armies of editors and proof-readers thought nothing of letting it stay. I am shocked too that someone like Grisham who has written sensitively about blacks in the racist South (A Time to Kill), would pen so prejudiced a thought. The fact that the comment appears without context, that there is no explanation either before or after of the rationale for such a preference and the fact that it is uttered by someone who is an "everyday" person makes it all the more chilling.
The second aspect is that the case made so convincingly at the beginning of the book against the over-commercialization of Christmas and all its attendant extravagances - is completely repudiated by the end of the book. In fact, the message of the book seems to be: it is okay if "marginal" people such as Buddhists or the Pakistani neighbors bypass Christmas. It is downright unChristian and unAmerican for other "normal people" to contemplate paring down in favor of simplicity or frugality or mere level-headedness.
I, for one, am quite offended by this message. The Kranks fall back on conventional wisdom - for no better reason than that they are too timid to go it on their own. It is not as if they sacrifice anything (consider "Gift of the Magi" by O'Henry), nor that they give to someone who is truly needy (consider Dickens' "A Christmas Carol"). The helpful eagerness of the previously disgruntled neighbors is like the triumph of proselytizers at having successfully converted two more reluctant souls to their religion. And what might that religion be? Materialism, of course. Let the cash registers ring.Ka-ching!!
All in all, a very disappointing book.
Amazon readers rating: from 1,036 reviews
Read a chapter excerpt from Skipping Christmas at MostlyFiction.com
(back to top)
Bibliography: (with links to Amazon.com)
- A Time to Kill (1988)
- The Firm (1991)
- The Pelican Brief (1992)
- The Client (1993)
- The Chamber (1994)
- The Rainmaker (1995)
- The Runaway Jury (1996)
- The Partner (1997)
- The Street Lawyer (1998)
- The Testament (1999)
- The Brethen (2000)
- A Painted House (2001)
- Skipping Christmas (2001)
- The Summons (2002)
- The King of Torts ( 2003)
- Bleachers (2003)
- The Last Juror (2004)
- The Broker (2005)
- Playing for Pizza (2007)
- The Appeal (2008)
- The Associate (2009)
- Ford Country: Stories (2009)
- The Confession (2010)
- The Litigators (2011)
- The Racketeer (2012)
- Sycamore Row (October 2013)
Theodore Boone series:
- Theodore Boone: Kid Lawyer (2010)
- Theodore Boone: The Abduction (2011)
- Theodore Boone: The Accused (2012)
- Theodore Boone: The Activist (May 2013)
Movies from Books:
- The Firm (1993)
- The Pelican Brief (1993)
- The Client (1994)
- A Time to Kill (1996)
- The Chamber (1996)
- The Rainmaker (1997)
and an original screenplay:
- The Gingerbread Man (1997)
(back to top)
- Visit the official Web site of John Grisham
- MostlyFiction.com review of The King of Torts
- MostlyFiction.com review of The Broker
- MostlyFiction. com review of Bleachers
- MostlyFiction.com review of The Confession
(back to top)
About the Author:
John Grisham was born in 1995 in Jonesboro, Arkansas; his father was a construction worker, his mother a homemaker. He majored in accounting at Mississippi State University and after graduating from law school in 1981, he went on to practice law for nearly a decade in Southaven, specializing in criminal defense and personal injury litigation. In 1983, he was elected to the state House of Representatives and served until 1990.
One day at the Dessoto County courthouse, Grisham overheard the harrowing testimony of a twelve-year-old rape victim and was inspired to start a novel exploring what would have happened if the girl's father had murdered her assailants. Getting up at 5 a.m. every day to get in several hours of writing time before heading off to work, Grisham spent three years on A Time to Kill and finished it in 1987. Initially rejected by many publishers, it was eventually bought by Wynwood press, who gave it a modest 5,000 copy printing and published it in June 1988.
Then he began his second novel, The Firm. He became an overnight success when he sold the rights to Paramount Pictures for $600,000. The Firm also became the bestselling novel of 1991. The successes of The Pelican Brief, which hit number one on the New York Times bestseller list, and The Client, which debuted at number one, confirmed Grisham's reputation as the master of the legal thriller.
Grisham publishes one novel a year and six of his novels of been turned into films. He also wrote the original screenplay, The Gingerbread Man.
Grisham lives with his wife Renee and their two children Ty and Shea. The family splits their time between their Victorian home on a farm in Mississippi and a plantation near Charlottesville, VA.