(Jump over to read a review of A Plague of Secrets)
(Jump over to read a review of Betrayal)
(Reviewed by Eleanor Bukowsky FEB 16, 2007)
“Listen up, Stuart—just as easily, the law could find that you did kill your wife, even if in fact, you didn’t. You’ve got to understand that and take it very, very seriously. The law is not about the fact of guilt or innocence. It’s about the settlement of disputes.”
A fifty-year old writer named Stuart Gorman is The Suspect in John Lescroart's engrossing new mystery thriller. Gorman's marriage to his wife of twenty-two years, Caryn Dryden, had been in trouble for quite a while. She was a brilliant and upwardly mobile orthopedic surgeon whose workaholic lifestyle did not mesh well with her husband's. A few days after Caryn asks Stuart for a divorce, she is found dead in her hot tub, a possible homicide victim. At his own admission, Stuart flew into a rage when Caryn insisted that their marriage was over. However, he denies having any role in his wife's death, claiming that at the time Caryn was killed, he was staying in his rustic cabin where he went to think things over. Upon his return, he found his wife's body and promptly called the police. Unfortunately, Inspector Sergeant Devin Juhle doesn't buy Stuart's story. After all, Gorman had motive and opportunity: he was clearly furious at his wife (who was insured for three million dollars), and his alibi is shaky. An eyewitness claims that she saw his car pull into his garage around the time that Caryn was killed.
Squarely on Stuart's side are his sister-in-law, the beautiful Debra Dryden, and Kymberly, Stuart's troubled eighteen-year-old daughter. The suspect also has an old friend, San Francisco State Assemblyman Jedd Conley, who convinces Stuart to hire criminal defense attorney Gina Roarke to represent him. Until now, Gina played a secondary role in Lescroarts novels. The main characters have usually been criminal defense lawyer Dismas Hardy and his best friend, Abe Glitsky, deputy chief of inspectors in the San Francisco Police Department. Now, forty-seven year old Roarke takes center stage and she is an appealing heroine. Still grieving over the death of her lover, the charismatic David Freeman, Gina finds herself at loose ends. She has difficulty concentrating on work and is reluctant to start dating again. However, taking on Stuart Gorman's case gives Gina the mental and emotional boost that she needs. She is soon convinced that her client is innocent, and she tackles his case with a tenacity and passion that she hasn't felt in years. The reader cannot help but root for Gina Roarke, who is handling her first homicide case and feels nervous and insecure about her ability to get her client off. Gina faces formidable obstacles, including an ambitious assistant DA eager to nail Gorman, and voracious reporters who are quick to try Stuart's case in the press.
Lescroart's cast of characters is varied and well-drawn. Wyatt Hunt, the chief investigator in Gina's law firm, is smart, funny, and supportive, and he capably handles most of the legwork for Gina. Devin Juhle is a dogged cop who stubbornly refuses to chase any leads that point to a suspect other than Gorman. One possible area of inquiry is Caryn's invention, known as the Dryden socket, which she created to repair hip joints. Caryn was about to withdraw the socket because of safety concerns shortly before the FDA was scheduled to grant its approval. Taking the socket off the market would have cost investors a great deal of money. Could this possibly have been a motive for murder? Before he is placed under arrest, Gorman decides to track down and interview some of Caryn's associates to learn more about what was going on in her life in the weeks before she was killed.
The Suspect is tightly written, carefully plotted, and fast-paced. It has beautifully written dialogue and a few welcome moments of humor to lighten the mood. Lescroart skillfully examines the psyches of his main characters and exposes the feelings that they keep hidden from public view. He also focuses on the unsavory aspects of human nature, such as duplicity, greed, and ambition, which often lead to violence. The courtroom scenes are compelling and the suspense builds steadily until a series of twists and turns brings the story to a slightly contrived but still satisfying resolution. Giving Gina Roarke her own novel was a smart move; she brings new life to a long-running series that had begun to show signs of age.
- Amazon readers rating: from 48 reviews
Chapter excerpt from The Suspect at the author's website
(back to top)
Bibliography: (with links to Amazon.com)
- Sunborn (1981)
Auguste Lupa Series:
Dismas Hardy / Lt. Abe GlitskeySeries:
- Dead Irish (1989)
- The Vig (1990
- Hard Evidence (1993)
- The 13th Juror (1994)
- A Certain Justice (1995)
- Guilt (1997)
- The Mercy Rule (1998)
- Nothing But the Truth (1999)
- The Hearing (2001)
- The Oath (2002)
- The First Law (2003)
- The Second Chair (2004)
- The Motive (2005)
- Betrayal (2008)
- A Plague of Secrets (2009)
- Damage (2011)
- The Ophelia Cut (May 2013)
Wyatt Hunt / Insp. Devin Juhle:
Gina Roarke / Insp. Devin Juhle:
- The Suspect (2007)
Music by the author:
- As the Crow Flies (2003)
(back to top)
- Official website for the John Lescroart
- Book Reporter review of The Hunt Club
- MostlyFiction.com review of The Betrayal
- MostlyFiction.com review of A Plague of Secrets
- MostlyFiction.com review of Damage
(back to top)
About the Author:
John Lescroart (less-kwah) was born in 1948 in Houston, Texas. John wrote his first novel in college and the second one a year after he graduated from Cal Berkely in 1970. However, he did not publish his first book until fourteen years later. His very first novel Sunburn became a reality when a former high school teacher's wife entered the book, in John's name, to the Joseph Henry Jackson Award given by the San Francisco Foundation for Best Novel by a California author. His book beat out 280 other entrants for the prize, including Anne Rice's Interview with a Vampire . Sunborn was published in paperback four years later.
Until he was 30, he hoped to make it as a musician and up to that point he concentrated more on his music than his prose. After 30, he switched his priorities. He supported his writing with a various day jobs including time as a computer programmer, an Ad Director, moving man, house painter, bartender, legal secretary, fund-raising executive and management consultant. At one point, he he enrolled in the Masters Program in Creative Writing at the University of Massachusetts at Amherst. However, one of his temp day jobs ended up making a lucrative offer and he and his wife never moved to New England.
About a year and half later, still squeezing writing in between day jobs, his wife encouraged him to try to publish some of his older manuscripts. He submitted Son of Holmes and six weeks later he had a hardcover book deal. For the next seven years, he was publishing but continuing to work his day jobs. Then at the age of 41, he contracted spinal meningitis and nearly died. After his 11-day battle, he quit his day job and moved back to Northern California.
He is now a New York Times bestselling author whose books have been translated into 16 languages in more than 75 countries. He still plays guitar and has written over 500 songs and owns a record label.